Homeopathy and the Biochemic System of Medicine (also called Schussler’s Tissue Remedies) are two holistic approaches that focus on stimulating the body’s natural healing ability.
However, they differ significantly in their principles, methods, and scope.
Understanding these differences helps students, doctors, and patients choose the right approach for various health conditions.
1. Fundamental Principle
Homeopathy – Based on the Law of Similars (“Like Cures Like”)
- A substance that can cause symptoms in a healthy person can cure the same symptoms in a sick person when given in diluted form.
- Example: Allium Cepa (Onion), which causes watery eyes, is used to treat colds with watery nasal discharge.
Biochemic System – Based on Cellular Deficiency (“Cell Salt Therapy”)
- Diseases arise due to a lack of essential mineral salts in the body.
- Treatment involves supplying the missing cell salts in potentized form.
- Example: Ferrum Phos. 6X is given for iron deficiency and inflammation.
2. Potency and Preparation
Homeopathy – Highly Diluted Remedies (Potentization)
- Homeopathic medicines are prepared using potentization, where substances are repeatedly diluted and shaken (succussed).
- Potencies vary widely (6C, 30C, 200C, 1M, CM, etc.).
Biochemic System – Low Potency Minerals (Trituration)
- Biochemic salts are prepared using trituration, where minerals are ground and diluted with lactose.
- Limited to low potencies (3X, 6X, 12X, etc.) to ensure cellular absorption.
3. Scope of Treatment
Homeopathy – Treats Physical, Mental, and Emotional Symptoms
- Works on the vital force (life energy) and can address deep-seated diseases.
- Treats chronic diseases, mental health issues, genetic tendencies, and acute conditions.
Biochemic System – Restores Physical Mineral Balance
- Works at the cellular level to restore tissue strength and function.
- Most effective for nutritional deficiencies, bone health, inflammation, and structural repair.
- Cannot address deep emotional or hereditary diseases.
4. Type of Medicines Used
Homeopathy – Uses a Wide Range of Substances
- Derived from plants, animals, minerals, and even diseased tissues (nosodes).
- Examples:
- Plant: Belladonna for fever
- Mineral: Sulphur for skin diseases
- Animal: Apis (Bee venom) for swelling
- Nosode: Tuberculinum for genetic predisposition to tuberculosis
Biochemic System – Only Uses 12 Inorganic Salts
- Based on Dr. Schussler’s 12 cell salts, which are naturally present in the human body.
- Examples:
- Calcarea Phos. – Bone and teeth health
- Natrum Mur. – Fluid balance and dehydration
- Ferrum Phos. – Inflammation and anemia
5. Dosage and Frequency
Homeopathy – Given Based on Symptom Similarity
- Single-dose or repeated doses depending on potency and case type.
- High potencies (200C, 1M) act deeper and need longer gaps between doses.
Biochemic System – Given Based on Deficiency
- Repeated frequently (3-4 times daily) for better mineral absorption.
- Given in low potency (6X or 12X) for long-term use without side effects.
6. Action Mechanism
Homeopathy – Works Through Energy and Vital Force
- The remedy stimulates the body’s self-healing process through energetic resonance.
- The medicine does not contain a physical substance in high potencies.
Biochemic System – Works at the Cellular and Nutritional Level
- Provides actual minerals in potentized form, which cells absorb to restore function.
- Works more like a nutritional supplement but in an energetic form.
7. Speed and Depth of Action
Homeopathy – Deep and Long-Term Action
- Can treat genetic predispositions, chronic illnesses, and emotional imbalances.
- Requires time and careful remedy selection for best results.
Biochemic System – Fast Relief for Physical Complaints
- Works quickly for acute issues like cramps, colds, acidity, and bone healing.
- Needs long-term use for chronic conditions.
8. Side Effects and Safety
Homeopathy – May Cause Initial Aggravation
- Can sometimes cause a healing crisis (temporary worsening of symptoms).
- Requires correct selection to avoid incorrect aggravations.
Biochemic System – Completely Safe and Non-Toxic
- No aggravations or side effects, even in pregnant women, children, and elderly.
- Safe for self-medication.
9. Use in Combination Therapy
Homeopathy – Individualized Treatment
- Remedies are often prescribed one at a time based on individual symptoms.
- Some remedies can be incompatible with each other.
Biochemic System – Can Be Used in Combination
- Multiple salts can be taken together without interaction.
- Combination formulas (e.g., Calc Phos + Ferrum Phos for anemia) are common.
10. Availability and Accessibility
Homeopathy – Requires Detailed Symptom Analysis
- Remedy selection is complex and requires case-taking by an experienced doctor.
- Remedies are available in various potencies and forms (liquid, globules, tablets).
Biochemic System – Easy to Select and Use
- Based on simple mineral deficiency signs.
- Readily available in tablet form and easy for self-medication.
Which System Should You Choose?
✅ Use Homeopathy for
- Chronic diseases (e.g., allergies, mental disorders, hormonal imbalances).
- Emotional and hereditary conditions.
✅ Use Biochemic Medicine for
- Mineral deficiencies (e.g., bone health, anemia, fluid balance).
- Quick relief from cramps, inflammation, and fatigue.
✅ Best Approach?
- Combining both systems gives the best results for many conditions.
- Example: Osteoporosis
- Homeopathy: Symphytum 30C for bone healing.
- Biochemic: Calcarea Phos. 6X to strengthen bones.
Conclusion
Both systems have their advantages.
Homeopathy is more suitable for deep, long-term healing, addressing mental and emotional aspects along with physical symptoms.
On the other hand, Biochemic Medicine is excellent for correcting mineral imbalances quickly and safely.
Understanding their differences helps in choosing the right approach based on the condition and individual needs.
The 12 Essential Cell Salts
- Calcarea Fluorica (Calc. Fluor.) – Strengthens bones, teeth, and skin elasticity
- Calcarea Phosphorica (Calc. Phos.) – Essential for bone growth and cell regeneration
- Calcarea Sulphurica (Calc. Sulph.) – Supports skin healing and detoxification
- Ferrum Phosphoricum (Ferr. Phos.) – First aid for inflammation and oxygen transport
- Kali Muriaticum (Kali Mur.) – Supports mucous membranes and detox processes
- Kali Phosphoricum (Kali Phos.) – The nerve tonic, combats stress and fatigue
- Kali Sulphuricum (Kali Sulph.) – Supports respiratory health and skin conditions
- Magnesia Phosphorica (Mag. Phos.) – Relieves muscle cramps and nerve pain
- Natrum Muriaticum (Nat. Mur.) – Regulates water balance and emotional well-being
- Natrum Phosphoricum (Nat. Phos.) – Balances acidity and aids digestion
- Natrum Sulphuricum (Nat. Sulph.) – Liver detox and bile production
- Silicea (Sil.) – Strengthens connective tissues, skin, hair, and nails.